Zuper Wins GeekWire’s Next Tech Titan Award!

Tips To Choose Between Appliance Repair vs. Replacement

Table of Contents

Has your appliance got a breakdown? Don’t panic! Breakdowns happen, but the repair vs. replace dilemma can be stressful.

You’re in the middle of making dinner, and your trusty fridge suddenly decides to take a break. A broken fridge during dinner prep or a washing machine on the blink during laundry day disrupts your routine. Calling a repair person is a good first step, but then comes the big question—fix it or get a new one.

Consider replacing your appliance if it’s a frequent repair visitor, an older energy guzzler costing you more on electricity bills, or has significant damage with repair costs nearing replacement price. Repairs might be better for minor issues, a reliable appliance with a small problem, or if it holds sentimental value.

Don’t hesitate to ask the repair service technician for their honest opinion on whether a fix will last. With some knowledge and an understanding of your appliance’s condition, you can make the best decision for your situation and keep your home running smoothly.

But here’s the big question. Is a repair enough, or is it time to say goodbye to your old friend? So what to choose? Even though you’re a homeowner, you can decide what’s best for your situation and your appliances.

Factors to consider when choosing appliance repair vs. replacement

1.Severity of the Issue

Think about how essential the appliance is to your daily comfort and routine. A broken air conditioner on a scorching summer day requires a much faster fix than a toaster that takes a little longer to brown your bread. Consider the cost of inconvenience, too. A malfunctioning washing machine might mean a trip to the laundromat and extra loads of laundry taking up your time. On the other hand, a fussy kettle might just mean waiting a little longer for your morning tea. Weigh the hassle factor against the repair cost to decide if a fix is worth it.

2.Lifespan of appliance

Older appliances may be less expensive to repair. Even after repair, the old one may cause future breakdowns and lack energy efficiency. At the same time, we should consider that new appliances are usually more expensive than repairing the old ones.


Consider the cost of repairs versus the cost of replacing the appliance. The cost-benefit analysis says a 50% rule helps you decide whether to repair or replace. If your appliance is more than 50% of its lifespan and the cost of one repair is more than 50% of buying a new one, you can try replacing rather than repairing.

4.Warranty considerations

Check whether the appliance is still under warranty. If the appliance breaks down within a period less than the warranty period, the best thing you can do is repair the appliance with a service professional from the manufacturer. If not, you may try fixing the appliance by considering other factors.

5.Energy efficiency savings

Modern appliances are designed with energy efficiency in mind. Replacing an old, inefficient appliance with a new, energy-saving model should also be considered. Energy-efficient models can significantly save energy bills. Using an energy-efficient appliance can save you a lot of money on your monthly electric bills.

6.Availability of parts

Sometimes, the availability of parts plays a role in deciding whether to repair or replace. Repairs may be complex if appliance replacement parts are not readily available for the appliance. If your appliance or equipment is old or rare, getting the necessary parts for repair will be challenging. You may have to wait for some extended period to get the required parts, which can affect your operations or productivity. In some cases, the delay caused by the waiting period could worsen the malfunction of your appliance.

Repair costs vs. replacement costs

Depreciation and energy efficiency

When it comes to appliances, the decision between repair and replacement often involves considering both depreciation and energy efficiency. Depreciation is the gradual decrease in the value of an asset over time. Appliances, like refrigerators, washing machines, and dishwashers, depreciate as they age. When faced with a malfunctioning appliance, one must weigh the cost of repairing it against its current value and expected remaining lifespan.

Energy efficiency also comes into play, especially in today’s environmentally conscious world. Newer appliances are often more energy-efficient than older models, meaning they consume less electricity or water while performing the same tasks. It’s nothing but lower utility bills and reduced environmental impact.

So, when considering whether to repair or replace an appliance, assessing its depreciation and energy efficiency is essential. Suppose a ten-year-old refrigerator breaks down, and the repair cost is high. On one hand, the fridge has already depreciated over its lifespan, so its current market value may be relatively low. On the other hand, newer refrigerators are much more energy-efficient than older models, potentially offering substantial savings on electricity bills. Replacing the old refrigerator with a new, energy-efficient one might make sense, even though it involves a higher upfront cost.

If a washing machine that’s several years old develops a leak and requires repair, the repair cost might be reasonable, but the appliance’s energy efficiency is worth considering. Newer washing machines often use less water and energy per load, leading to savings over time. If the old washing machine is relatively inefficient compared to modern models, replacing it with a more energy-efficient one could be a wise investment despite the initial expense.

Similar to washing machines, dishwashers can become less efficient as they age. A dishwasher nearing the end of its lifespan might require frequent repairs to address issues like leaks or malfunctions. While repairing the dishwasher might seem like a cost-effective solution in the short term, replacing it with a newer, energy-efficient model could offer long-term savings on water and energy bills.

Advantages of repair vs replacement

Repairing your trusty appliance instead of replacing it can be a wallet-friendly and eco-conscious choice. Let’s break down why you need to prefer repairs.

Save money

Repair costs are often much lower than buying a brand-new appliance. Even if the repair seems major, fixing it can extend the appliance’s life, saving you a bundle in the long haul.

Environmental friendliness

Opting for repair reduces electronic waste and lessens the environmental impact of producing new appliances. It’s a small step toward a greener planet.

Familiarity and comfort

You’re used to your appliance’s quirks and features. Repairing it keeps your home routine intact without the learning curve of a new machine. Plus, there might be sentimental value attached to your trusted appliance.

Quality parts

Skilled repair technicians use top-notch parts, ensuring your appliance runs smoothly for years. There is no need to worry about shoddy replacements— your appliance is in good hands.

Support local services

Hiring a local repair pro supports your community and keeps skilled technicians in business. It’s a win-win for you and your neighborhood.

While repair isn’t always the answer, considering these perks can help you decide whether to stick with your reliable appliance or go for an upgrade.

Disadvantages of repair vs replacement

When weighing the choice between repairing your trusty appliance or opting for a shiny new replacement, it’s essential to consider the allure of brand-new appliances. While repairs have their perks, here are some reasons why and when to replace appliances:

Frequent breakdowns

Constant repairs can quickly add up, becoming a recurring expense. If your appliance seems to break down more often than not, investing in a new, more reliable model might be more cost-effective in the long run.

Outdated technology

Older appliances, while familiar, may lack the energy efficiency and advanced features of newer models. Upgrading to a modern appliance can save you money on utility bills and offer improved performance over time.

Limited availability of parts

Finding replacement parts for older appliances can be a challenge. If repairs aren’t feasible due to part availability, replacing the appliance might be your only solution to restore functionality.

Safety concerns

Safety should always be a top priority. If your appliance poses a safety hazard, such as gas leaks or faulty wiring, repairs may not be an option. In such cases, replacing the appliance is crucial to safeguard your home and family.

Aesthetics and functionality

Let’s face it—appliances have a lifespan. Modern appliances often boast sleek designs and enhanced functionality compared to older models. Upgrading to a new appliance can add a touch of style to your home while providing improved features and convenience.

Remember, the decision to repair or replace depends on your specific circumstances. Weigh the perks and drawbacks carefully, considering the age and condition of your appliance, the repair cost, and the potential benefits of a new model.

Simple tricks to keep appliances running longer

To maximize the efficiency and longevity of your appliances, diligent adherence to manufacturer-provided maintenance schedules is paramount. These schedules encompass a range of tasks, from routine cleaning to filter checks and lubrication of moving components, all crucial for preserving optimal functionality. Tailoring cleaning techniques to suit each appliance’s unique requirements is essential.

For instance, meticulous attention to detail when cleaning refrigerator condenser coils or addressing frost buildup is pivotal for maintaining peak performance. Before enlisting professional assistance, exploring troubleshooting tips from appliance manuals or online resources can often resolve common issues swiftly. Adherence to guidelines provided in the user manual is equally critical for guarding against behaviors that could undermine the lifespan of an appliance. 

When contemplating appliance replacements or upgrades, thoroughly evaluating factors like efficiency, functionality, and cost-effectiveness, guided by professional advice and exhaustive comparisons, is indispensable. When looking for repairs or replacements tailored to specific brands, such as LG or Viking appliances, leveraging localized online searches will help you discover reputable repair services within your vicinity.

DIY appliance repairs every homeowner should know

Changing filters and belts

  • Regularly clean the lint trap in your dryer after each use to prevent lint buildup, which can reduce airflow and pose a fire hazard. Also, inspect and replace the dryer vent hose if it becomes damaged or clogged.
  • Replace the water filter in your refrigerator every six months or according to manufacturer recommendations to maintain water quality and prevent clogs in the water dispenser and ice maker.

Unclogging drains

  • Use a drain snake or a mixture of baking soda and vinegar to unclog sink and shower drains. It helps prevent backups and water damage in your home. Also, regularly clean drain stoppers to remove hair and debris.

Replacing seals and gaskets

  • If the door gasket on your refrigerator is damaged or worn, replace it to maintain proper sealing and energy efficiency. A worn gasket can lead to air leaks and increased energy consumption.
  • Replace worn oven door seals to prevent heat loss and ensure even cooking. A damaged seal can result in temperature fluctuations and uneven baking or roasting.

When to seek professional help

While homeowners can handle many repairs, some issues require the expertise of a professional appliance repair technician.

  • Qualified professionals should address issues with gas appliances such as stoves, ovens, and dryers to avoid safety hazards and ensure proper installation and repair.
  • Electrical problems in appliances should be diagnosed and repaired by licensed electricians or appliance repair technicians to prevent electrocution or further damage to the appliance and your home’s electrical system.
  • If your refrigerator or air conditioner is leaking refrigerant, it’s crucial to enlist the help of a professional HVAC technician to identify and fix the leak safely. Refrigerant leaks can pose health risks and should be addressed promptly by trained professionals.

Seek a service professional to help

When your trusty appliance starts acting up, the question arises: Should you tackle the repairs yourself or call a professional? While there is no shortage of DIY videos promising a quick fix, the reality of appliance repair can be quite different. Facing a malfunctioning appliance can be stressful. Diagnosing the problem and executing repairs can be time-consuming and frustrating, especially for complex issues. 

Hiring a professional offers complete peace of mind, allowing you to step back and let them handle the situation. Even the most intricate appliance repair rarely takes a professional a whole day. Their experience and training enable them to quickly identify the root cause of the problem and implement a lasting solution. 

This rapid turnaround time is nothing but getting your appliance back in action sooner, saving you time and inconvenience. DIY repairs often address immediate symptoms without tackling the underlying issue. This can lead to recurring problems or even make the situation worse. A qualified technician will have the expertise to diagnose the root cause and implement a permanent fix, ensuring your appliance functions optimally for years to come.

Appliance repairs can involve electrical components and potential hazards. Hiring a licensed and insured professional ensures the job is done safely and according to industry standards. This protects you from possible injuries and electrical dangers. Sometimes, appliance malfunctions stem from minor underlying problems that an untrained eye can easily miss. These can snowball into more significant issues later on.

A skilled technician has the experience to spot these potential problems early on, preventing future headaches and saving you money in the long run. Many professional appliance repair services offer warranties on their repairs, giving you peace of mind knowing that their work is guaranteed. This eliminates the worry of shoddy maintenance or needing to redo the job yourself. Professional appliance repair technicians can access specialized tools and equipment to diagnose and fix complex issues. 

Tackling repairs without the proper tools can further damage your appliance or pose safety risks. Hiring a local appliance repair service injects money into your community and supports skilled technicians. You’ll be contributing to the local economy while receiving expert service. On the other hand, DIY appliance repairs might seem tempting, but the advantages of hiring a professional are undeniable. Their expertise, efficiency, and commitment to safety can save you time, money, and frustration in the long run.

Wrapping up

In some situations, repair is the more practical choice, particularly for appliances that are still relatively new or have minor issues. Professional repair technicians can diagnose and fix problems efficiently, extending the lifespan of your appliance and saving you money in the short term. Whether you opt for repair or replacement, prioritizing regular maintenance and addressing issues promptly can help prolong the lifespan of your appliances and ensure they continue to function efficiently for years to come. Remember, a well-maintained appliance is reliable, providing convenience and comfort in your daily life.

While appliance repair costs may seem high upfront, hiring a professional for complex appliance issues is a wise and worthwhile investment. Enjoy worry-free appliance service by hiring skilled and licensed appliance repair technicians.

Like this Blog ? Share it with your friends

Related Blogs

Learn More About
Zuper Today

Get started with a free Zuper trial account and explore on your own how you can improve your field service operations, or schedule a demo today with our product experts!
Free Trial